Secondary

Looney Tunes Characters' Colors

New 27 Jul 2024 Asked by bokkiedoke 4 Comments

Would most Looney Tunes character be primary or secondary Red? Most of them are pretty impulsive and very emotional, even the more measured characters like Bugs Bunny and Marvin the Martian throw a fit and attack people regularly.


Certain genres lean toward a certain color like horror and black.

Color Identity of Foghorn Leghorn

New 26 Jul 2024 Asked by you-are-a-fishmonger 6 Comments

What do you think foghorn leghorn's color identity would be (sorry if this has been already asked)


Primary red, secondary green.

Color Pie Break/Bend

New 19 Jul 2024 Asked by quantext 3 Comments

Would Finest Hour be considered a color pie break/bend today?


I think white is secondary in extra combat steps, but we do the effect so infrequently that’s it’s tough for secondary to get many cards.

Squirrels Secondary Color Justification

New 19 Jul 2024 Asked by quantext 4 Comments

Why was black chosen as the secondary color for squirrels?


It started because it fit a card I was making in Unstable. That started the ball rolling. I think black feels like a good fit as Squirrels aren’t too far away from Rats.

Question on Concordant Crossroads

New 16 Jul 2024 Asked by deathworld12 5 Comments

is concordant crossroads a bend break or neither?


Green is secondary in haste. Usually granting the ability is more for the primary color than the secondary, but we do allow the secondary color to do it a little. The rate is probably too good, but that’s not a color pie issue.

Analysis of Spock's Color

New 07 Jul 2024 Asked by you-are-talking-about-this 31 Comments

Is Spock UW?


Yes. He’s core blue, secondary white.

Request for Mono-Blue Spell

New 26 Jun 2024 Asked by honor-basquiat 1 Comments

May I please request a mass blink/flicker spell with a mono blue color identity?There multiple versions of this effect that are mono white (i.e. Another Round, Semester's End, Ghostway, Eerie Interlude) and there have been some that have White and Blue color identity too (i.e. Brago, King Eternal, Disorder in the Court, Yorion, Sky Nomad). It would be really nice to have some that are mono blue for Commander purposes!


White is primary in flickering and blue is secondary, so mass flickering is more a white thing. That doesn’t mean blue can never get it, but it needs the right set.

Hypothetical Mono Colored Set Archetypes

New 23 Jun 2024 Asked by 3-slugcat-pilots-7-ornithopters 3 Comments

In the hypothetical mono colored set would there be just 5 draft archetypes?


I assume there would be secondary two-color archetypes.

Questioning Lukka's Secondary Color

New 13 Jun 2024 Asked by kaptain-kota 5 Comments

Is Lukka secondary Green or White?


Probably white.

BR Card's Permanent Destruction

New 12 Jun 2024 Asked by brushaber87-blog 16 Comments

Can a BR card have “destroy target permanent”? I know BG and BW can do it but I’m unsure what holds back BR. Per the 2021 color pie articleCreature - B primary W secondaryEnchantment - W/G primary B secondary Artifact - R/G Primary W secondary Planeswalker - B primary G tertiaryLand - R primary B/G tertiaryBattle - unknownUsing the above BR is the only color combo that doesn’t use a tertiary ability


We like to focus effects in a small number of colors, so just because two colors can destroy any permanent doesn’t necessarily mean we want to make cards in that color combination that do so.

Outlaws of Thunder Junction

New 10 Jun 2024 Asked by space-wizards 73 Comments

"Innistrad is one of my best designs."Yeah, Innistrad was great when it was unique, and gothic horror is an incredibly deep well to draw from. There's tons of source material, and it's easy to make it feel "universal".These days, it feels like every premier set is trying to be Innistrad, unless it's a Storyline Set or a Return Set. The Innistrad-likes all feel like "Magic does [genre]" instead of something actually original, Storyline Sets are practically Return Sets, and the actual Return Sets are half Innistrad-likes anyway.The Modern Horizons sets are the last bastion of bottom-up, Magic doing Magic sets, but they're infrequent, expensive, and overshadowed by how they destroy the Modern metagame every time.I just want a new world that makes me feel like I'm reading the Planeswalker's Guide to Alara again. A world that only makes sense in Magic the Gathering, instead of Magic fitting itself into something that already exists.


I want to begin by stressing something. You’re talking to me, the Head Designer of Magic. I, along with rest of the designers, are in charge of the mechanical execution of design. We create the larger structure of how the set is build, weave in flavorful themes, and design mechanics to play into that structure and theme(s). When I talk about sets I’ve done I’m talking about the part of the process I’m in charge of. With that said, let’s talk about the latest design I led (vision design), Outlaws of Thunder Junction. I hold up its game design to any other set I’ve lead. The mechanics are sharp, useful, and lead towards new play patterns. The limited play and constructed play involving its themes are novel. And while it’s all forward facing, it was designed to be more backwards compatible than previous sets. Plot, in particular, is one of the most exciting new mechanics I’ve designed in a long time. It’s simple in description, but surprisingly deep in strategy. Having the primary focal point of villainy, with a secondary theme of the Western genre, led my team to create something new. Top-down is just an input. Good design can come from any input. Bottom-up design is no better at making good mechanic designs than top-down. I believe current mechanical design is on point, and Outlaws of Thunder Junction, in particular, is my team being on their A game.

Miku Secret Lair Bonus Cards

New 08 Jun 2024 Asked by hyralc 121 Comments

I just got my Miku secret lair and generally I'm very happy with it; it looks gorgeous. However, I must comment frustration that there's two separate bonus cards, with a difference of rarity it seems, no less. It sucks that 'oh actually there's another Miku card you don't get without going to the secondary market which will absolutely ratchet up the price." This feels different to the more generic bonus cards like the slivers which weren't attached to any one secret lair


Two questions: (for everyone to answer) 1) Do you prefer the bonus to be connected to the Secret Lair theme or separate? 2) Do you like the ability to occasionally get rarer bonus cards, or would you prefer all of them get the same thing?

Considering Slickshow Showoff’s Abilities

New 01 Jun 2024 Asked by blind42-blog 35 Comments

Slickshot Showoff has prowess but both points go to power. What color would this but +2 toughness show up in? Blue?


White is primary in toughness pumping, but we do so little these days. Blue is secondary.

Beast Boy’s Colors

New 30 May 2024 Asked by kaptain-kota 25 Comments

Is Beast Boy monoGreen or Gruul?


It depends what storyline, and how many colors you want. I think Gar is primary green, secondary red.

Hypothetical Design Changes

New 16 May 2024 Asked by mudthing 12 Comments

Hi Mark! Maybe you’ve been asked this before, but - in a utopia where Magic costs nothing to produce or to buy, and you don’t have to worry about sales or the secondary market, would there be changes in how you design?


That’s a very interesting question, but one that’s so complex it’s hard to answer. It’s kind of like figuring out what chairs would like like if our knees bent the other way. It forces you to completely rethink so many things that are engrained into the process, that it gets mind-melty.

Cyclops's Color Identity

New 12 May 2024 Asked by kaptain-kota 18 Comments

What would you color Cyclops from X-Men?


He’s white at his core, secondary in red.

Tertiary Abilities Rule

New 09 May 2024 Asked by thunderweb 27 Comments

I have a question about tertiary abilities not being used on multicolor cards.https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/making-magic/mechanical-color-pie-2021This article says Trample is tertiary in White, Blue, and Black. Does it mean there shouldn't be a WUBRG or GWUB creature with trample, even if Green is the primary color for it?


Tertiary abilities shouldn’t be that color’s contribution to a gold card. As long as a multicolor card has a color that’s primary or secondary in the ability, all is good. For instance, a green/blue multicolor card can have trample, because trample is primary in green.

Color Coding Changes

New 05 May 2024 Asked by jimreviewsthickshakes-blog 23 Comments

Hey mark! I enjoyed your alphabet podcast, but I might have another one for you. When guilds of Ravnica came out, R&D referred to the nightveil predator cycle of cards as costing CCDD. Does that give you an entry for D?


D moved to N when C moved to M. Now the translated version of that sentence. We used to use C to mean any colored mana, so if we were making a tight cycle (all the cards have the same mana value) where all the costs cost two generic mana and one colored mana, we’d write it as 2C. If we were making a cycle of two-colored multicolor cards, we’d use D for the second color. For example, if it was a tight cycle with two generic mana and one of two different colored mana, we’d write it as 2CD.But then Oath of the Gatewatch came out and we introduced colorless mana in costs. We needed a letter for that, so we used C for colorless. That meant we had to change the old usage of C as it would make a cost of 2C ambiguous. We changed from C to M to mean any colored mana. When we changed it to M, we changed the secondary color to N as N follows M like D followed C.

Lifelink in Green/Red

New 04 May 2024 Asked by phenax-god-of-reception-blog 25 Comments

Would it theoretically be possible for a green/red creature to have lifelink? Not necessarily permanently, maybe temporary through activation or through a specific trigger. Green has access to lifegain, and red often cares about damage, so something with both hurt and help makes thematical sense.


Lifelink isn’t primary or secondary source n either color, so I’m skeptical we’d do that.

Black's Interaction with Prowess

New 02 May 2024 Asked by visioncrown 24 Comments

could black get prowess? it's the color that cares the most about noncreature spells after red and blue, correct?


No. Black, green, and white all can care about noncreature spells in different ways. Blue is primary in prowess, red secondary, and white tertiary.


Portions of Marodigest are unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Magic: The Gathering, including card images and mana symbols, is copyright Wizards of the Coast, LLC. Marodigest is not produced by or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. All other content © 2024 Webscape Internet Engineers. All rights reserved.