Orc

Card Compatibility with Force of Will

New 27 Jul 2024 Asked by elmdormesdoram 7 Comments

One with Nothing is the strongest card in the game, but it has a huge problem: it can't be pitched to Force of Will! Can we have a version of that effect that costs U/B (hybrid)?


I don’t believe every card needs to be pitched to Force of Will. : )

Black's Game Dynamics

New 26 Jul 2024 Asked by krobat 3 Comments

Can Black still turn creatures into 0/2s like Sudden Spoiling or Sorceress Queen?


It’s not in black’s slice of color pie, but more bend than break.

Appreciating Monty Python Secret Lair

New 26 Jul 2024 Asked by joeyfog 4 Comments

I have to say, the Monty Python Secret Lair is amazing. High Fives to everyone involved, especially those who came up with Tim on Prodigal Sorcerer


: )

Blue's Permanent Effect on Creatures

New 24 Jul 2024 Asked by janeasterisk 1 Comments

would it be in pie for blue to permanently remove a creatures abilities with an instant/sorcery? or is that too close to removing and replacing it?


Unlikely. If an instant or sorcery, it would be temporary. For a permanent effect, we’d use an aura.

Ubiquitous Tokens Expectation

New 21 Jul 2024 Asked by gcu-sovereign 4 Comments

Is the Ubiquitous Token of a plane something we should expect from visit to visit? Like, how Capenna has its gw citizens, Innistrad has black decayed zombies, LTR had orc armies [applicable to some silmarillion-based visit, I guess]I was looking at the Fish tokens in Bloomburrow and Mercenaries in otj and wondering if those were also more Worldbuilding statements or not.


It’s a mechanical tool that adds flavor, and something we definitely use when shaping a set.

Rules and Subtypes for Land Creatures

New 20 Jul 2024 Asked by summonsequence 1 Comments

Is there a rules reason Omo cannot give all creature types to land creatures? Was that too confusing? Did it break something on arena? I’ve been pondering this and can’t figure it out.


You can’t give a subtype of a specific card type to a different type (with the exception that instants and sorceries share subtypes).

Sorcery Speed Pingers Implication

New 14 Jul 2024 Asked by marcantoniosavelli 2 Comments

Would sorcery speed pingers solve the problem of too much complexity in combat and allow pingers to be printed in standard?


They don’t change the math much. Yes, it’s different for first strike/double strike.

Chatterfang's Homeland Uncertainty

New 14 Jul 2024 Asked by noybusiness 6 Comments

I'd like to point out that if Chatterfang, Squirrel General is now from Bloomburrow, that would be a retcon, because his bio in "The New Legends of Modern Horizons 2" mentions him fighting drakes and orcs, which apparently don't exist in Bloomburrow.


I do not know where Chatterfang is from.

Rules Distinction in Gift

New 11 Jul 2024 Asked by gridnack 7 Comments

First of all, LOVE Bloomburrow! Especially the otters, frogs, and rabbits. Re: Gift a tapped fishGift is like Haunt in that the instant/sorcery version and permanent version do different things. The spell gifts the fish before other effects. The permanent gifts when it enters. I see this having similar challenges with Haunt. Also the rules text doesn’t specify a 1/1 blue fish. Reminder text isn’t technically part of the rules. Can I gift my opponent other kinds of fish? I see the “gift a tapped fish” as being potentially “rules-challenging”.


Rules text has meaning beyond what’s on the card. Reminder text is telling you relevant information. That is real information that has rules weight. Reminder text just isn’t written in technical Magic templating.

Design of Brave-Kin Duo

New 09 Jul 2024 Asked by silverswordofhope 27 Comments

The recently spoiled Brave-Kin Duo having both a mana cost and a sorcery restriction on its ability seems unnecessarily cautious.Some of my all-time favorite cards are the cheap combat-tricks on a body like Angelic Page, Ghost Warden, Infantry Veteran, Anointer of Champions, etc. Is there a reason we don't see those much anymore? They make for super interesting combat. As they're not really competitively viable cards these days, it would be cool to see a more pushed version (like a 1MV Ghost Warden).Or if it has to have a mana cost, why not a +1/+1 *counter* like a Cenn's Tactician that can target any creature? That would be super fun.


This is a common card designed for limited. The power level is adjusted to that goal.

Changeling Role in Typal Sets

New 09 Jul 2024 Asked by tevans-living-life 40 Comments

Does Bloomburrow prove that a typal-themed set doesn’t need changeling to work? Or will Changeling stick around for typal sets with heavier creature type emphasis?


The as-fan of typal themes is a lot lower than sets like Lorwyn or Ixalan. “Here’s a snippet from my article today that touches upon this:To give you a sense of what I mean by a sprinkling, here are the typal rewards for Frogs:
  • A common that costs less if you have a Frog
  • An uncommon sorcery with a rider if you have a Frog
  • An uncommon land with an effect that helps Frogs
  • An uncommon land and a rare creature that cares if a Frog entered the battlefield this turn
  • An uncommon creature and a rare creature that grant Frogs an ability
  • A rare creature that cares about casting Frogs
The number of typal cards can vary slightly, but that will give you a rough idea of the as-fan I’m talking about.”Here’s a link to the whole article:

CEDH Staple Card Availability

New 08 Jul 2024 Asked by lrhall94universe-blog 4 Comments

As someone who plays mostly CEDH there are a few staples that are not reserve list that tend to just be generally hard to find even though they are not expensive, while secret lairs have introduced new arts and inventory for some of these cards certain cards like demonic consultation, tarnished citadel, and orcish lumberjack are still hard to comeby in good condition. i know you guys can't reprint everything all the time but maybe expressing CEDH meta cards in reprint sets helps people enter into this growing sub-sect of a fun and exciting format; Cheers and Looking forward to MTGxMarvel and FF


I can pass along the request.

Possibility of New Frames

New 08 Jul 2024 Asked by smrgnt-blog 31 Comments

Hi Mark,If or when: Instants/Sorceries getting their own frame like Artifacts and (nyx-bordered) enchantments do, possibly in a limited capacity to start with, as a trial run perhaps?


If, but it’s been discussed.

Magic's Core Fantasy Expressions

New 03 Jul 2024 Asked by a-thug-changes 34 Comments

While I'm not a fan of sneakers in Magic, I do appreciate your responses to some of the recent questions. I think back to how kooky stuff has always been a part of magic. From Arabian Nights, to cards like Orcish Lumberjack, magic _has_ always been weird. Recently its just the core fantasy is taking a back seat to corny tropes and pandering. We got UB, were told its not for everyone, and then immediately got UB-esque content in premier sets, repeatedly. Excited for the pendulum to swing back.


Bloomburrow is the pendulum swinging back on that front. It is core high fantasy.

Boldness in Spell Restrictions

New 03 Jul 2024 Asked by nothingbutland-blog 4 Comments

I just listened to your restrictions podcast. But restricted spell casting and even abilities were baked into the game in Alpha, Sirens Call, Camouflage, False Orders could only be played at specific times, Neteling Imp could only be activated at a specific time and Veteran Body Guard only dud his Kevin Cosner impression if untapped. Not to mention the interupt, instant and sorcery timing rules.


There have always been restrictions. We’ve just been more bold in where and how often we can use them.

Understanding Instant and Sorcery

New 01 Jul 2024 Asked by blaze-1013 9 Comments

Someone asked for "instant that becomes stronger or gains an additional effect when cast at a time you could cast a sorcery" and you've made those already in Born of the Gods with the Fated cycle.


Yes.

Speculating on Future Game Mechanics

New 01 Jul 2024 Asked by melancholia-ennui 4 Comments

If/when: An instant that becomes stronger or gains an additional effect when cast at a time you could cast a sorcery - similar to Addendum, but requiring an empty stack as well?


If. I’m skeptical we’ll ever require an empty stack.

Keyword Action Considerations

New 01 Jul 2024 Asked by masu-lw 10 Comments

Ever since Mill was made an official keyword action in M21, have there been any other Magic colloquialisms/slang you've also wanted to the same for? (For example, writing "Force" as a keyword on cards instead of "rather than pay this spell's mana cost.")


I have never heard people use the term “Force” outside of the specific card Force of Will, and even then, quite rarely. Is this commonly used?

Freerunning versus Prowl

New 01 Jul 2024 Asked by fisyx 7 Comments

Do you have any insight as to why the team for ACR went with "freerunning" as the mechanic vs using "prowl" and making the spells "kindred instant/sorcery - Assassin"? Obviously with the commander clause its different, but they've talked about how that was added later on.


We use kindred very infrequently.

Trivia Request: Primal Forcemage and Timbermare

New 29 Jun 2024 Asked by foobar137 6 Comments

Mark - first off, I wanted to thank you for all you do for the game and its players. I’ve been playing Magic since Revised, and while I keep drifting in and out, you’ve been the anchor that keeps me involved with the game.Second - I request birthday trivia. Specifically, do you have any interesting trivia on the centerpieces of my first FNM deck, Primal Forcemage or Timbermare?


Timbermare was a nod to “Mare”, the wife of a Magic writer named Jamie Wakefield, who died of cancer. Happy Birthday!


Portions of Marodigest are unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Magic: The Gathering, including card images and mana symbols, is copyright Wizards of the Coast, LLC. Marodigest is not produced by or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. All other content © 2024 Webscape Internet Engineers. All rights reserved.