Phasing

Phasing in Blue

New 18 Jul 2024 Asked by fresh-young-doggo 5 Comments

Hey I wanted to ask about phasing, personally I’m not a fan of it in blue. I feel like it gives blue too many answers.


Blue is the color of bounce and flickering. Who better to get phasing?

Land Destruction Alternatives

New 08 Apr 2024 Asked by horizonsgift 33 Comments

If the concept of Land Destruction causes player ire, yet old heads like me think it’s a vital stop gap, can we sidestep the problem? Phasing them out for X turns or X number of stun counters? Functionally the same, less feelsbad than the straight Armageddon.


Phasing them out causes most of the same issues.

Third Mirage Expansion?

New 07 Apr 2024 Asked by luvkraft 21 Comments

Hi, Mark.
Is it possible that something like a third expansion will be added to the Mirage block, just like Cold Snap was added to the Ice Age block over time? (since Weatherlight is like episode zero of the Rath cycle) (although I have a feeling Prophecy is the third)


Weatherlight was still the third block of the Mirage block. It does have flanking and phasing cards in it.

Updating Game Mechanics

New 12 Mar 2024 Asked by thenuclearotaku 28 Comments

Follow up to my recent question about upgrading mechanics: like I said, it's become more of a recent trend to either introduce new mechanics as upgrades of older ones (Disguise, Cascade, Blitz) or even just tweaking old mechanics to make them a bit more intuitive to use (Hideaway, Amass, Phasing).Is this a conscious and active effort on R&D's part? Or is it more a product of the game's long lifespan? I.e. you can only create so many new mechanics before you have to start reinventing the wheel, so to speak.


Design technology keeps improving and the game keeps adapting. Good mechanics can fall out of favor due to changes, so updating them is just good design practice.

Phasing Bands Speculation

New 17 Feb 2024 Asked by aalgot 31 Comments

If/when “bands with other creatures with phasing”


Big if. : )

Flicker vs Phasing

New 11 Jan 2024 Asked by blaze-1013 25 Comments

A brief run down of the differences between flicker and phasing. Flicker protects against all targeted removal and delayed flicker from all removal. It nombos with Voltron strategies and tokens but has bonus synergy with leave/ETB triggers plus resets cards (say an undying creature). Phasing meanwhile offers no synergies positive or negative but AFAIK all phasing is long term so will protect against anything. When coupled with hexproof and Indes I enjoy the range of protection options we have.


Each has its positives and negatives, and we want access to both.

Phasing vs Exile

New 11 Jan 2024 Asked by aramisuvla 21 Comments

Piggybacking on recent questions about exile; many effects that temporarily exile feel like phasing, or at least like phased out. For example, flickering or banishing effects, and suspend spells. One recent card, The Moment, uses phasing this way ("phases out until..."). Has R&D considered giving phasing a bigger role in the game for these sorts of effects? That would seem to make a path towards a world where exile really means "gone forever".


There are things that effects like flicker do that work differently than phasing in a positive way.

Phased Library Confusion

New 04 Jan 2024 Asked by aalgot 35 Comments

what happens if my library phases out while it is a creature?


It’s phased out (and phasing out doesn’t make the card leave the battlefield). You’ll probably lose when you can’t draw a card.EDIT: Oops. I messed up. The rules don’t prevent you from drawing off a phased out library.

Phasing Out Counters

New 13 Dec 2023 Asked by edibleashell 31 Comments

Good evening Mark, could/would the rules ever support the phasing out of only counters? Something like "all counters on target creature phase out until end of turn"?


I don’t believe the rules support that.

Phasing Colors

New 08 Oct 2023 Asked by mistymountainsgay 37 Comments

Is caring about things phasing in or out part of white's color pie? Growing up with mirage, I'd've thought it was blue, but we got that WB card in LOTR and now the War Doctor in WR. Also I think phasing matters is a super cool direction considering the changes to phasing no longer being tied to the old keyword--which I guess is why it's no longer blue.


“Phasing matters” is white and blue.

Instant Supertype Possibility

New 05 Oct 2023 Asked by temporarynameiwillchange 43 Comments

Is there any chance in hell of Instant being made a supertype and phasing out Flash (so what's currently an Instant would be an Instant Sorcery and what's currently a creature with flash would be an Instant Creature) or would that be too much to change?


Inertia is a tricky beast. If we started over, I would absolutely do it. Is there a chance of us doing? I won’t say no, but I’d say the chance is pretty small.

Vehicles vs Sagas

New 20 Jul 2023 Asked by jjustin1379 51 Comments

Vehicles are pretty good but sagas are better and yet vehicles are in every set and u won't even make sagas deciduous. Phasing is deciduous. Think about that. Which mechanic is better? Obviously sagas


Sagas *are* deciduous.

Doctor Who Exclusion

New 11 Jun 2023 Asked by shin-trans17 56 Comments

I'm not a very big fan of Warhammer nor Lord of the Rings, but I'm a huge fan of Doctor Who. Now knowing there won't be a planeswalker version of the doctor came as a huge surprise considering they are probably the closest of what a planeswalker is outside magic. Why no planeswalkers? I really love them (in fact my three commander decks are built around them - Lord Windgrace, 5-Color Superfriends and a Chandra "tribal" deck) and it feels like wizards is phasing them out in favor of legendary creatures...


We’re not getting rid of the card type. It’s just not being used outside of Wizards IPs.

Surprising Standard Mechanic

New 20 May 2023 Asked by stormtide-leviathan 44 Comments

What would past maro be most surprised to hear is on multiple cards in standard: affinity, phyrexian mana, or phasing out?


Probably phasing out. : )

RnD Perspective Timing

New 18 Mar 2023 Asked by narnalubat 31 Comments

Regarding chronal displacement you mentioned earlier - reminded of something I've always been curious about. When you tell us the "current" thinking of RnD on a topic (what's moving where in the color pie, what mechanics are now or are no longer deciduous, etc), do you tend to answer from "this is what RnD thought 2 years ago" or "this is what RnD thinks today?" You made it clear stun counters are the latter, but I remember other examples (return of deciduous phasing) being the former.


I normally try to talk in terms of what you all are experiencing, but I can occasionally mix it up.

Blue Creature Removal

New 10 Mar 2023 Asked by j-waffles 54 Comments

You’ve said that blue isn’t supposed to get creature removal like Pongify anymore, the transformations should either be temporary or on auras. That being said, is phasing of zhalfir a bend or break? It’s basically just a mass Pongify, and since it’s it’s from DMR, half the time it’s just a sorcery that only says the third chapter


It’s a major bend on the third chapter of a Saga. Things can slip through as we’re phasing things out of colors (pun intended, of course).

Anti-Bounce in Commander

New 05 Mar 2023 Asked by sjtsquid 43 Comments

I'm guessing that a lot of the anti-bounce questions are commander players looking for counterplay to Cyclonic Rift.

White gets anti-bounce in phasing, for what it's worth.


Blue also gets phasing.

Phasing's Design Evolution

New 21 Dec 2022 Asked by nadojo1 33 Comments

Just a heads up on your recent storm scale article you have phasing listed as a 9, that's likely because of how phasing used to work. But it has become far more common in design since it's rework.


That’s phasing as a creature ability like it occurred in Mirage (aka here every other turn). The deciduous ability is phasing out. That said, I get the confusion and will change the 9 example in my next Storm Scale article.

Spell Phasing Possibility

New 21 Dec 2022 Asked by televangelist2 25 Comments

Hi Mark, thinking about stack interactions that haven't been used yet -- can the rules support 'target spell phases out', targeting a spell on the stack? Either with a choice of new targets when the spell phases back in, or with the spell fizzling unless its original target is still valid?


Phasing only can affect things on the battlefield, I believe.

Phasing vs Exiling

New 20 Dec 2022 Asked by clevibert 37 Comments

Is there any benefit to having something permanently phase out vs exiling it?


They mechanically do slightly different things.


Portions of Marodigest are unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Magic: The Gathering, including card images and mana symbols, is copyright Wizards of the Coast, LLC. Marodigest is not produced by or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. All other content © 2024 Webscape Internet Engineers. All rights reserved.