Planes

Werewolves on Different Planes

New 27 Jul 2024 Asked by zozocracked 3 Comments

If you did werewolves on a different plane, do you think they’d still be TDFCs, or would you do them different? And if they were TDFCs, do you think their Transformation condition would be the same or different?


I think we’d probably make Werewolves on another plane singled-faced.

Death Race Planes Availability

New 27 Jul 2024 Asked by chairsarefornerds 10 Comments

do we know how many planes death race will take place on?


Three. Two are worlds that have been the main setting of a premier set and one which hasn’t (although has been referenced).

Death Race Planes Announcement

New 27 Jul 2024 Asked by noybusiness 3 Comments

I hope which three planes Death Race is set on will be announced at Comic-Con.


It will not be.

Considerations on Multi-Plane Sets

New 23 Jul 2024 Asked by icarusfrommars 4 Comments

With how many new planes we've gotten, with some of them up in the air if we'll ever see them again, despite how popular they may be, has the team begun to lean into the idea of more multi-plane sets? It's the main reason I'm looking forward to Tennis/Death Race and I think there are a lot of interesting avenues that could be taken in both story and gameplay potential for multiplane sets, but what's the mood around the office for those kinds of sets?


Let’s see how Tennis goes.

Likelihood of Revisiting Planes

New 21 Jul 2024 Asked by krobat 4 Comments

Taken on the whole, irrespective of anything specific about the plane, is a new plane more likely to be revisited at some point or not be?


We more often return to worlds than never return.

Request for Specific Planeswalkers

New 21 Jul 2024 Asked by shahrathestoryteller 6 Comments

Hi Mark! May I please request Worzel and Thomil: Magic's first planeswalkers from all the way back in Magic's first story in the Magic: The Gathering Pocket Player's Guide in Modern Horizons 4 (if there is one)?


We’ve talked about them getting cards.

Trivia on 'Love Song of Night and Day'

New 19 Jul 2024 Asked by mistymountainsgay 6 Comments

Before my birthday is over, I would love to invoke my right of trivia!Anything about my favorite part of Magic's world, the Love Song of Night and Day? Or if not, Mirage in general? (I fell in love with Magic when I found my parents' old collection of Mirage and 4th Edition, making me probably the youngest grumpy old magic player to ever shake their fist at these new confangled planeswalker cards)


The Love Song of Night and Day was a poem written by Jenny Scott when she was an editor on Magic. Pieces of it were used on flavor text in Mirage block. I would later read the poem at a wedding at a Magic Grand Prix. We would also eventually making a Saga that referenced it.Happy Birthday!

Potential for Other D&D Planes

New 19 Jul 2024 Asked by darcskies17 1 Comments

Hey Mark first I want to thank you for what you and your team do. Is it possible that we could get other D&D planes as sets. Faerun has a lot of history but there are other planes that could be awesome Inspiration for MTG?


It is possible.

Release of Sultai Planeswalker

New 19 Jul 2024 Asked by waluigisbulge 1 Comments

If or when, A sultai planeswalker? (and the other missing groupings of colors, I'm a bit surprised we haven't seen one for each of the three color groupings yet)


I assume when, but at the slow rate we make them currently, it might be a while.

Question on Reprinting Sets

New 19 Jul 2024 Asked by j-waffles 14 Comments

Re: “we’ve promised to not straight reprint old sets.”When you say this, do you mean that you won’t print a set with the exact same set list as an existing set? Or do you just mean that you won’t print cards that are indistinguishable from existing versions? That is to say, if you made a hypothetical “return to ravnica redux” where everything was the exact same with no changes, except all the cards had a little planeswalker stamp in the corner like the list or mystery booster, would that be fair game?


It means we won’t reprint a set with the exact same cards, frame/text upgraded or not.

Appreciation for Bloomburrow

New 17 Jul 2024 Asked by skagerrakgodofdarkness 8 Comments

Can I just saw I LOVE the planeswalkers guides for bloomburrow, I grew up on Redwall and it’s been super fun to see ,, I especially love how there’s no clear villain type, and each group is shown to have positive and negative attributes. High fives to all involved!


High fives to be applied.

Unifying Ox and Minotaur Types

New 16 Jul 2024 Asked by josphitia 11 Comments

Has there ever been any thought to combining the Ox and Minotaur creature types? Such as simplifying both to simply "Cow?" I'm a huge fan of bovines in all forms and it would be nice if all of the Ox in magic worked alongside their more anthropomorphic cousins the Minotaur. As it is now we're lucky to really get cards of *either* type printed. There's resonance to the name Minotaur, no doubt, but it also has its share of baggage. It has Greek connotations and that's probably a big reason Minotaurs are almost strictly in Theros (although some favorites, such as Neheb, are from other planes). I was happy that Outlaws had more Ox cards, but it also highlights my dissatisfaction: Holy Cow is an *ox* not a cow, despite the name. It feels like a retread of the Hound or Naga debacle all over again. Hound was simplified to Dog and all Snakes, from rattlesnakes to Naga, are simply the type Snake now. This allows snakes and dogs of all walks benefit from a shared unity. Cats had it right, we didn't need Leonin as a separate type.I just feel like there's unnecessary separation being created by dividing Ox and Minotaur and it has the same resonance failings as all dogs being labeled "hounds" had. If it's important for a particular creature to *be* a minotaur then they can just *have* minotaur in their name, like ~30% of minotaurs already do. There's also the simple fact that Minotaur is a longer average creature type, limiting design space for other types to be included. It's hard to justify why a Minotaur is on a random plane, but much less so if it's simply a "Cow Warrior" for example. As for why I think "Cow" should just be the combined type name, I simply think it fits. Cow is a resonant name. Almost everyone, East to west, knows *of* cows if only because their milk is such a widely used commodity. We don't call it "Ox's milk" after all. More than that, it's fun! Cow is *funny* in the same way *squirrel* is funny. It's amusing to see "Squirrels you control" in this game full of fighting. In that vein, "Cows you control" is an amusing line that can help break up the seriousness of a setting. I know this is making a mountain out of a molehill, but magic is a game of different perspectives coming together and creating something new. Cows are my favorite animal and it's simply dissatisfying, to me, that my Holy Cow can't benefit from a Kragma Warcaller. That Angrath, colloquially named "Cow Dad" in the community, would have the creature type "Minotaur." The only downside I can see is that "Cow" *does* specifically refer to females of a bovine species. But that is a distinction few, if any, seriously take into consideration. If one sees a field of cows, they're not saying "I see lots of cows and 3 bulls!" They're going to say "I see cows!"So to bring the thesis back, has there been any discussion internally to simplifying the Minotaur and Ox creature types under a single banner, such as "Cow?" I would also happily settle for "Cattle" as the new type. I just feel the current Ox vs Minotaur divide has to go, for both flavor and mechanical reasons, and the sooner the better.


I have been on Team Cow (as I was on Team Dog) for many years. I even made Cows in Un-sets. I still believe Minotaur should be its own creature type though.

Appreciation for Planeswalkers Guides to Bloomburrow

New 16 Jul 2024 Asked by jimhensonreject 17 Comments

I can't give enough high fives to everyone at wizards that made sure there would be THREE Planeswalkers Guides to Bloomburrow. It makes me unbelievably happy to see it not just live up to the worldbuilding and depth I'm used to in a Magic setting, but exceed it. A plane doesn't feel like a plane without it!


We have heard that message loud and clear.

Alternatives for Set Additions

New 16 Jul 2024 Asked by brendo 3 Comments

Since the decision seems to be that you won't be returning to blocks, have you guys considered other ways of including additional sets for beloved planes? I think some interesting ways to do it could be by having modern horizons/commander legends sets focused on a single plane.


The mixing and matching of old mechanics would make it tricky to do a Modern Horizons set on one world.

Surprises in Plane Reactions

New 14 Jul 2024 Asked by jacw212 1 Comments

As someone who has New Capenna in their top 3 favorite planes, I was really surprised that it wasn't beloved. Were you ever surprised by a lukewarm reaction to a plane you liked, or a very warm welcome to a plane you were unsure about?


I expected Kaladesh to be a bit more beloved.

Sales Trend and Future Strategy

New 13 Jul 2024 Asked by dissociativehusky 7 Comments

I have a sales question. LOTR, I believe, is the best selling set of all time, right? And if I recall, the best selling commander set of all time is Fallout, behind that being Warhammer. Goes to imply the Marvel sets will likely be the next highest selling sets of all time, if not just behind LOTR. My question is, doesn't this show WOTC should mostly just pivot to UB as the new 'standard' with old planes as the less visited product?


While will continue to do Universes Beyond as there is an obvious audience, but the Magic in-universe sets (which we call “MIP sets”) also serve an important function. There are a lot of fans who love Magic’s IP, and having sets that we have don’t have to interface with outside partners has a lot of advantages.

New Planes and Returns

New 11 Jul 2024 Asked by doopboopdoop 6 Comments

Could we ever see a year where it's all new planes and then the following year is returns to all of them?


We usually wait to see response to a world before returning to it. That mixed with our lead time would make this hard to do.

Game-End Effects and Emblems

New 11 Jul 2024 Asked by captain--wasabi 9 Comments

Why do "until the end of the game" effects are not reworded as emblems? The only card that got the treatment is Elspeth, Knight-Errant


We mostly use emblems for planeswalkers.

Bloomburrow Animals' Strength

New 11 Jul 2024 Asked by bhogal83 8 Comments

Do the animals on Bloomburrow have super-strength? Like, many of them are small mice/frogs/etc, yet they have power/toughness higher than humans from other planes.


Making all creatures have fractional power and toughness wasn’t on the table. : )

Mechanics - Old vs New

New 11 Jul 2024 Asked by misenaive-blog 1 Comments

Hey Mark, just wanted to say that I'm a big fan of graveyard mechanics and seeing Threshold return in Bloomburrow as well as Delirium in Duskmourn has made me really happy. I would like to ask how do you balance using returning mechanics vs creating new ones when designing sets in completely new planes.


If an old mechanic will accomplish what we need, we try to use the old mechanic, but there are a lot of factors that can make us want to use something new instead.


Portions of Marodigest are unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Magic: The Gathering, including card images and mana symbols, is copyright Wizards of the Coast, LLC. Marodigest is not produced by or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. All other content © 2024 Webscape Internet Engineers. All rights reserved.