Commander 2017

O-kagachi Spirit Tribal

New 06 Oct 2019 Asked by elderdragonmaster55 42 Comments

Back in commander 2017 O-kagachi was the legend I was most hype for due to spirit tribal but it doesn’t have a synergy or lord ability for spirits so If or when: a new legend or second version of O-kagachi is 5 color that actually a spirit tribal legend?


I often talk about my desire for stripping the rules from the legendary supertype. That’s always met with a majority opinion not to do that. Well, one of the side effects of keeping it, is there are certain conflicts that push us away from making things legendary because of it. One of the biggest things is tribal effects.If a tribal card is designed so you’d want to have multiples in play at once, there’s a disincentive to make it legendary as it would prevent the card from functioning at its maximum capacity. Not all tribal effects stack and sometimes we throw Commander a tribal bone, but this is the tension with legendary tribal creatures.That said, if we make a new O-kagachi I’ll pass along the request for Spirit tribal.

Future Weatherlight Crew

New 20 Jul 2019 Asked by ralinski 40 Comments

Good Day Mark. Mirri got a new version in Commander 2017, so is it possible we'll get more new versions of the old Weatherlight crew in the future?


It is very much possible. Sissy got a new card in Modern Horizons, for example.

Tribal Themes Inspiration

New 28 Jan 2019 Asked by rhoxosgsaint 30 Comments

In recent DTW you said Dominaria set's tribal wizard theme came out because of twitter's head-to-head result. Is head-to-head also the cause of Commander 2017's wizard? I always thought Dominaria's wizards type is closely related with Commander 2017's one.


I put the Wizard theme in. It was directly inspired by the Head-to-Head results.

Weatherlight Crew Return

New 12 Jan 2019 Asked by ultradefinitelynotathrowawa-blog 49 Comments

If/when. New versions of the old Weatherlight crew in a supplementary set like Commander.


Definitely when. A new Mirri was in Commander 2017.

Birthday Trivia Request

New 16 Sep 2018 Asked by brij4074-blog 48 Comments

Hi Mark, I normally forget to ask for Birthday Trivia but I remembered this year! I was wondering if you had anything for Licia?


Lucia came about because Commander 2017 saw the opportunity of a red/white/black Vampire deck to allow players to combine the black/red Vampire of Innistrad with the white/black Vampires of Ixilan. Licia was designed as a top down red/white/black Vampire. Happy Birthday!

Dragons and Future Sets

New 10 Mar 2018 Asked by centurosplaneswalker 48 Comments

You've done seeding for 3 of the 4 commander 2017 tribes in current Standard (as of Dominaria). So this makes me think Dragons are being left out - is this a clue we're going back to Tarkir soon?


Or that players just really like Dragons.

Teferi's Return Hinted

New 10 Mar 2018 Asked by arachnigamer-blog 71 Comments

Was Teferi's protection in commander 2017 meant to seed the idea of Teferi coming back?


Yes. : )

Vampire Synergies

New 17 Oct 2017 Asked by codenamejd 24 Comments

In your odds and ends article you point out that you planned for Mardu vampires in commander 2017 to be followed by Orzhov vampires in Ixalan, knowing people would want to mix Ixalan and Innistrad vampires. Did you not think the same for Amonkjet and Innistrad Zombies? With cards like Necromancer's Covenant?


We knew that players would play Amonkhet Zombies with Innistrad ones.

Tribal Themes in Sets

New 21 Sep 2017 Asked by famouskoalarebel 38 Comments

In R&D, did anyone have any reservations about having Commander 2017 have a tribal theme so close to Ixalan?


No, we liked the thematic synergy.

Commander 2017 Reprint

New 31 Aug 2017 Asked by mikluemp-blog 60 Comments

Will there be more of c17 printed? My lgs and local walmart were sold out of the dragon deck on release day.


Yes, we are reprinting Commander 2017.

Twitter Brackets Insight

New 19 Aug 2017 Asked by greatglasslynx 51 Comments

What cool things have you learned from your Twitter brackets?


Gavin just revealed that Wizards doing well in the first Head-to-Head encouraged him to make it one of the deck choices for Commander 2017.

Commander 2017 Angel Query

New 14 Aug 2017 Asked by mafiaiguana 40 Comments

Hey there, excited about Commander 2017 but curious as to why Angels didn't get a deck and their first 5 color legend. Could you shed some light? :)


There were lots of possibilities and only four decks. Not everything that could have been done was done.

Commander 2017 Tribes Coincidence

New 11 Aug 2017 Asked by simicmimic 49 Comments

I noticed all four of the Commander 2017 tribes were in your Top 20 Creature Types podcast. Coincidence?


: )

Werewolves in Commander 2017

New 11 Aug 2017 Asked by ceta-maelstrom 34 Comments

Were werewolves ever on the table for commander 2017?


The print run numbers of a supplemental set make double-faced cards tricky to do. So, no.

Edgar Markov's Design

New 11 Aug 2017 Asked by gonnaaskmarkwhymarkovisweirdme 36 Comments

I know you didn't have too much to do with commander 2017 (to my knowledge) but there is something that I would be eternally grateful if you could help shed some light on the reasoning and design process. That question is why does Edgar Markov have nothing related with gaining life? The card itself could simply be B/R and no one would bat an eye. Flavor wise it's even more of a mystery seeing as every single iteration of Sorin, who is his own grandson, has something to do with life gain.


Sorin is his own man. : )

Cats Color Spectrum

New 11 Aug 2017 Asked by cxrrxw 71 Comments

Is there anything to stop us getting cats in a colour other than green and white?


In normal sets, no. In the green/white Commander 2017 Cat deck? Yes.

Commander 2017 Surprises

New 11 Aug 2017 Asked by piogre 73 Comments

We've now seen that Commander 2017 has Phasing, *and* pseudo-storm. Is this the biggest upset we'll see to the storm scale in this set, or should we brace ourselves for a card with "Bands with Other"?


Again, the Storm Scale is for Standard-legal sets.

Tribe Selection Strategy

New 10 Aug 2017 Asked by rtrt227 234 Comments

Love commander 2017, but a little upset you guys didn't make a tribe that was previously inaccessible, possible. All of the tribes chosen were already among the most popular, and powerful.


Two things: 1) We don’t get to add that many new cards. 2) We’re trying to sell the decks. Picking already popular tribes is a lot less risky.

Commander 2017 Lineup

New 09 Aug 2017 Asked by milktaoist 20 Comments

An earlier mark made me wonder - has the full Commander 2017 lineup been announced? I'm trying to figure out what colors and tribes the decks will be, but all I can find is GW cats and WUBRG dragons.


Stay tuned. Each day is showing off a new deck.

Commander Previews Timing

New 08 Aug 2017 Asked by a-deg 59 Comments

Did you consider starting Commander 2017 previews with the Dragon Day so the Cat previews could have been on International Cat Day (August 8th)?


If we had realized that today was International Cat Day when we planned previews, we print badly would have swapped things around.


Portions of Marodigest are unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Magic: The Gathering, including card images and mana symbols, is copyright Wizards of the Coast, LLC. Marodigest is not produced by or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. All other content © 2024 Webscape Internet Engineers. All rights reserved.