Chronicles

Chronicles Counting

New 15 Apr 2019 Asked by perfectlydarien 49 Comments

I would suggest that counting Chronicles separately from Fourth Edition makes no more sense than does counting Alpha and Beta as separate sets. It was packaged in different packs, but was considered to be an extension of Fourth Edition, and was legal everywhere (and everywhen) Fourth Edition was; it didn't occupy an "expansion" slot in Type 2, and it rotated along with Fourth Edition when Fifth Edition came out. It should probably not count.


I agree that counting Chronicles seems odd. Thoughts?

100th Set Criteria

New 15 Apr 2019 Asked by thalain-deactivated20190905 39 Comments

If the exact criterion for inclusion is "set that was once standard legal", WAR is the 100th because Chronicles was at its time a Type II legal set. It wasn't considered an expansion (the official designation was an extension of 4th edition), but it is a set. 18 core + 81 expansions + Chronicles = 100.


Interesting. Let me look into it.

Dakkon Blackblade Reprint Inquiry

New 22 Nov 2018 Asked by spiritkhan 34 Comments

Can i request a reprint of Dakkon Blackblade?


Is he on the Reserved List? I think not because I believe he was in Chronicles. If he’s not on the Reserved List, he could get reprinted in a supplemental set.

Reserved List Policy

New 11 Apr 2018 Asked by morganwe 66 Comments

One thing that really bothers me about the reserve list is why, if it's a good policy, does Wizards not update it? Why is it okay to protect older players' collections from losing value, but not my newer cards? What makes Modern Masters acceptable, but not Chronicles? It seems to be a double standard.


The Reserved List is a promise we’re living up to, but not one we want to recreate.

Reserved List Discussion

New 29 Dec 2017 Asked by gophilipbowles 41 Comments

I'm not sure where the commentator who suggested 35% of the top 40 Legacy cards are on the reserved list got his list from. The MtGGoldfish version of the list has only Lion's Eye Diamond in the top 40 cards played, and none in the top 20. This excludes lands, but a very simple solution for the reserved list would simply be to backdate the original condition (cards not reprinted in 4th, Ice Age or Chronicles) to cards not reprinted in Revised or later.


I believe the number came from counting up the actual cards played in winning decks (not individual names, actual cards played counting each individual copy). And yes, the largest amount of that is the dual lands, but they’re not leaving the Reserved List so you have to count them. In short, when the world can’t play the required mana base of the format, it’s a poor format to push worldwide.

Narnia Influence Speculation

New 21 Jun 2017 Asked by 3mice-deactivated20190928 30 Comments

Hey Mark, it's my birthday today! Do you have any Magic Trivia about how the Chronicles of Narnia might have influenced any part of the game?


I don’t know if any concrete connection, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t any. Richard is well read and loves fantasy, so there’s a strong chance it had an influence, just not one I’m aware of.Happy Birthday!

Animal Planeswalkers

New 15 Jun 2016 Asked by coriell1 75 Comments

Do you think we could ever see a hyperintelligent animal as a planeswalker? Something like Aslan from Chronicles of Narnia?


Possibly.

Unlimited Print Risks

New 01 May 2016 Asked by luckylooter 32 Comments

What would the consequences be of printing Modern Masters 3 at an unlimited quantity?


I suggest reading some articles about what happened with Chronicles and Fourth Edition.

Reserve List Creation

New 01 May 2016 Asked by daysundoing 19 Comments

For those of us who weren't around then, what was done to upset players and thus create the reserve list?


Chronicles and Fourth Edition reprinted numerous older cards that were hard to acquire in large quantities.

Reserved List Opinion

New 09 Dec 2015 Asked by ttip23 45 Comments

On Phyrexian Negator and the Reserve List, Chronicles burned me and I quit the game. Today, I think it would be healthy to have some loopholes. I have less respect for WotC sticking to a policy that benefits far fewer people today than it used to.


We’ve done research on opinions on the Reserved List. The pro-Reserved List crowd stays mostly silent on social media, but it’s a much bigger number than I assume most of you guess it is.

Nebuchadnezzar Reprint Issues

New 03 Jul 2015 Asked by simicpower 27 Comments

Nebuchadnezzar isn't on the Reserved List. It was reprinted in Chronicles.


Good point. Okay, it’s name (and legendary status) *is* probably holding it back.

Modern Masters Rarity

New 19 Feb 2015 Asked by notreallygoodatcommingupwithname 48 Comments

Why was Tarmogoyf, Bob and Vendilion Clique raised to mythic rarity in the first Modern Masters? Were you just scared of experiencing a Chronicles 2.0? In the past you have said that complexity and balancing for limited formats define the rarity of a card. Are there going to be any changes to the rarity of cards that are going to be in Modern Masters 2015?


I said those two were the major factors. They are not the only ones. The tricky balancing act of Modern Masters products is getting the cards into the hands of players who don’t own them without destroying the value of the cards for players who do own them.

Nicol Bolas Trivia

New 03 Jan 2014 Asked by jadedragon55-deactivated2017120 15 Comments

Today is my birthday! Nicol Bolas is my favourite character since I first pulled him in a pack of Chronicles. Any bit of trivia about him or another legendary dragon would make my day, please!


I remember talking to the lead designer of Legends, Steve Conard, many years ago and he was surprised that Nicol Bolas was the break-out Elder Dragon Legend. He thought it was going to be Arcades Sabboth. Happy Birthday!

Historical Challenges

New 06 Aug 2013 Asked by troy-costisick-blog 12 Comments

In five years when you do the silver anniversary of Magic, perhaps you can amend your "20 things that Almost Killed Magic" to include 5 things that actually almost did like: overprinting Fallen Empires, following up the Chronicles debacle with a set like Homelands, the Over-powered-ness of Urza's block, following up Urza's block with the utter crappiness of Masques block, and Time Spiral's block of overcomplicated mess? I think each of those put the game in more danger than Nalathni Dragon.


The article was more about controversies than things that were actually in danger of killing the game. I just chose an attention-grabbing headline.

Podcast on Chronicles

New 01 Aug 2013 Asked by calintares 2 Comments

So you can'y do a podcast about the reserved list, but can you do one about Chronicles?


Same issues.

Modern Masters Print Run

New 28 Jun 2013 Asked by jeanlucncoelho 14 Comments

Don't you think modern masters' print run was too low? Can't you make another print run to make it more accessible?


My best answer to this question is to study Magic history and see how Chronicles made that mistake and all the bad things that happened as a result.

Reserve List Background

New 23 Mar 2013 Asked by quantumecho-deactivated20130825 11 Comments

I'm sure you get tons of questions about the Reserve List, but I had some queries about its history that you hopefully haven't seen a million times. Can you tell us under what circumstances the Reserve List was created, and maybe give us some background into the decision? Why are some cards that are fairly balanced by today's standards and aren't particularly valuable (things like Thunder Spirit and Aeoliphile) on the List? Thanks!


The Reserved List came about in reaction to the release of Chronicles and Fourth Edition edition back in 1995. Both sets included cards that previously were very hard to obtain. Many players complained and Wizards in response made the Reserved List as a promise that they wouldn’t do this again. The Reserved List was all the rare cards from the sets at the time (and also the uncommons of the core set but those later got removed) that had not yet been reprinted. Wizards at the time then promised that each year they would tag a certain percentage of the rare cards (80% is my memory) and those cards would be added to the list. The 20% that wasn’t added were cards that were allowed to be reprinted. Right before Mercadian Masques came out, Wizards said they were stopping the adding of cards to the Reserved List. Note that the 20% were cards Wizards at the time believed were reprint able, but other than that the cards on the Reserved List weren’t about power level but rarity.

Reserved List Support

New 07 Mar 2013 Asked by donthemage 29 Comments

As always, when the issue of who supports the Reserved List comes up, feel free to dime me out. I support the Reserved List wholeheartedly. Ask the folks who want to abolish the Reserved List what they were playing when Chronicles was released.


Most people don’t speak up when they know there is a vocal majority so thanks for demonstrating that Reserved List supporters do exist.

Reserved List Perspective

New 25 Jul 2012 Asked by donthemage 8 Comments

I'm pro Reserved List, and I don't mind saying so. Most of us folks are the ones who remember the game when it was billed as a collectible card game and not simply a trading card game. The differences in expectations (at least in my opinion) are based on that concept. Most of the folks who are anti-Reserved List weren't around for Legends and Chronicles. I don't think there's a good way to explain why us pro Reserve List folks feel the way we do, unless you were there at that time.


I posted this so people can see that there are those for the Reserved List. My only bone of contention is that Wizards has always referred to Magic as a trading card game. Really, it’s printed in the Alpha rules book. “Collectable card game” was made up by our competitors who didn’t want to use the same name as us.

Mana Order Reasoning

New 30 Mar 2012 Asked by ssteki-blog 6 Comments

Sorry if this as been addressed before. Some multicolored cards follow the order of WUBRG in their mana cost. WUBRG cards cost WUBRG, UB cards are UB, etc. But other cards like WG cards cost GW and WR cards cost RW. Why is that?


Here is Del Laugel, Magic’s lead editor answering this question in a 2002 Ask Wizards question: Q: "Why do mana symbols seem out of order on various gold cards? Some cards requiring green, white, and blue mana, like Treva’s Charm (Green ManaWhite ManaBlue Mana), have it in that order. Some cards, like Phelddagrif(1 ManaWhite ManaBlue ManaGreen Mana), go white, blue, and then green. Rubinia Soulsinger (2 ManaBlue ManaWhite ManaGreen Mana) goes blue, white, green. Shouldn’t there be more organization?“
– Cid Silhouette, Boston, MA A: From Del LaugelMagic technical editor:
"As you’ve noticed, three different systems have been used in the past to order mana symbols on cards. One system always put the colors in the order white-blue-black-red-green, and that ordering was used for Ice AgeTempest, and Chronicles. Another goes clockwise around the "pentagon of colors." Mirage block used that ordering, and we’ve been following it consistently since Stronghold. And then there’s the Legends system, which involved throwing mana symbols into a hat and then pulling them out at random. "Our current (and final!) system for ordering mana symbols is pretty simple. If you look at the back of a Magic card, you’ll see the pentagon of colors. Going clockwise, the colors are white, blue, black, red, green, white, blue, black … . To order a pair of mana symbols, find them in that list, and then put them in whichever order puts the fewest colors between them. For example, white/red has two colors in the middle (blue and black), but red/white has only one (green). That’s why Goblin Legionnaire’s mana cost is Red ManaWhite Mana. "Then came the Apocalypse 'wedge’ cards. Our system breaks down when you’re trying to order two friendly colors and their common enemy, and Apocalypse has five rares with mana costs that fall into that category. For Lightning Angel’s mana cost, 1 ManaRed ManaWhite ManaBlue Mana and 1 ManaWhite ManaBlue ManaRed Mana are equally valid options. In the end, I decided to put the enemy color pair first. ”(Yes, I know that the Apocalypse split cards all violate the color order. It was decided that those five cards would be easier to name that way.)“


Portions of Marodigest are unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Magic: The Gathering, including card images and mana symbols, is copyright Wizards of the Coast, LLC. Marodigest is not produced by or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. All other content © 2024 Webscape Internet Engineers. All rights reserved.