Modern Horizons

On 5-color Legendary Angel

New 26 Jul 2024 Asked by sapphic-asymmetries 10 Comments

Hi Mark! Curious as a huge angel fan: If/When 5-color legendary angel?Also All my thanks and many high-fives to the team for mh3, I've gotten so many friends into magic because of it!


I assume when. We make a lot of Angels. I’m glad you and your friends like it.

Enjoyment from Marvel Sets

New 24 Jul 2024 Asked by windows-media-playa 5 Comments

Gooday sir! I call upon the sacred right of birthday trivia to ask you about your favorite set to open packs from. I only really started playing when UB LOTR released and since then I've had some fun pulls including Ulamog showcase from MH3. I would love to see what luck brings from your favorite set to rip into.


I’ve been enjoying opening packs from upcoming Marvel sets. : )

MH3 Flip Walkers Control Rules

New 21 Jul 2024 Asked by werhsdnas-blog 4 Comments

Is there a flavor reason why the MH3 flip walkers return to the owner's control and not the control of the person who flipped them?


I think it’s how the rules work. A new card (as far as the game is concerned) that hasn’t entered the game yet doesn’t have a controller.Someone better versed in the rules could explain the nitty gritty.

Reception of Modern Horizons 3

New 21 Jul 2024 Asked by honor-basquiat 2 Comments

How successful was Modern Horizons 3? Did its reception meet your expectations?


It’s doing very well. Expectations met. : )

Request for Specific Planeswalkers

New 21 Jul 2024 Asked by shahrathestoryteller 6 Comments

Hi Mark! May I please request Worzel and Thomil: Magic's first planeswalkers from all the way back in Magic's first story in the Magic: The Gathering Pocket Player's Guide in Modern Horizons 4 (if there is one)?


We’ve talked about them getting cards.

Preference Between Modern Horizons 4 and Future Sight 2

New 20 Jul 2024 Asked by waltertusk 2 Comments

The core of the supplemental set issue is that players want a Future Sight 2 type of set to exist, but we all buy the crap out of Modern Horizons, which occupies the "high complexity deep cuts" slot, so Wizards will always pick making a Modern Horizons 4 over a Future Sight 2


For curiosity:

Which would you prefer? Modern Horizons 4Future Sight 2No preference

Raising Bar for Supplemental Sets

New 20 Jul 2024 Asked by blazinjsin 12 Comments

"Why has the bar for supplemental sets gotten higher? Is it universes beyond?Universes Beyond and Modern Horizons are the biggest two causes." That really sucks, a lot of us really looked forward to the summer supplemental sets because of how fun they were, 2 headed giant draft and conspiracy immediately come to mind.


The bar gets raised because new products do well. More players play them, more players buy them, and more players rank them higher in market research. It’s not some diabolical plot. It’s the game evolving towards what the players are most enjoying.

Supplemental Sets Bar Rising Cause

New 19 Jul 2024 Asked by ak-47osu 5 Comments

Why has the bar for supplemental sets gotten higher? Is it universes beyond?


Universes Beyond and Modern Horizons are the biggest two causes.

Reprinting text-less full art

New 19 Jul 2024 Asked by brendo 4 Comments

Hey Mark, could cards be reprinted as text less full arts with the same art they already had? I just saw Campbell White's art for the elemental incarnation cycle in the MH3 special guests for the first time, and think that it actually gets hurt by the text box blocking a bit of it, and think it would be really cool if versions with just the art could exist.


It depends on the art ratio.

Handling Modern Horizon Card Influx

New 17 Jul 2024 Asked by puresmoulder 6 Comments

If we can acknowledge that a number of players have complaints with the "card influx" from Modern Horizons sets causing the power level of formats to spike drastically, do you have any insights on how this issue is going to be tackled, or if it's even something that needs to be fixed at all?


It’s an issue being examined. The issue is many players enjoy the higher powered designs of the straight to modern sets.

MH Sets and Power Creep

New 16 Jul 2024 Asked by smtmtg 15 Comments

Hey Mark! Not to be confrontational or anything but can we, at this point, say that the MH sets (specially mh3) caused power creep? The meta on the pro tour was pretty rough. Thanks for all your hard work!


It raised the power level of the format. That happens whenever enough new (relevant) cards enter a format. Before we starting making cards for Modern (when sets were mostly focused at Standard), the influx of (relevant) new cards was low, so format churn was low. Olds cards did get forced out by new cards, but it happened at a much slower rate. That’s not what “power creep” is. So, if you want to be unhappy with format churn due to products being created with a higher power level as they’re aimed at Modern, that’s very reasonable. It’s a “card influx” complaint not a “power creep” complaint.

Alternatives for Set Additions

New 16 Jul 2024 Asked by brendo 3 Comments

Since the decision seems to be that you won't be returning to blocks, have you guys considered other ways of including additional sets for beloved planes? I think some interesting ways to do it could be by having modern horizons/commander legends sets focused on a single plane.


The mixing and matching of old mechanics would make it tricky to do a Modern Horizons set on one world.

Chatterfang's Homeland Uncertainty

New 14 Jul 2024 Asked by noybusiness 6 Comments

I'd like to point out that if Chatterfang, Squirrel General is now from Bloomburrow, that would be a retcon, because his bio in "The New Legends of Modern Horizons 2" mentions him fighting drakes and orcs, which apparently don't exist in Bloomburrow.


I do not know where Chatterfang is from.

Philosophy behind Snow Wastes

New 10 Jul 2024 Asked by hugsandambitions 5 Comments

In the past, you've mentioned a philosophy of not designing something just to check boxes. Ie, not making an Energy-Matters legendary Homunculus just because you haven't yet. Because of that, when Snow Wastes were shown in MH3 I thought there'd be a snow archetype, but there wasn't. Were Snow Wastes an exception to the box-checking philosophy?


Yes.

Missing Titan Text Explanation

New 08 Jul 2024 Asked by dullwitandravens 3 Comments

Is there a reason why you seem to no longer print cards with the "when this is put into your graveyard, shuffle yard into library" text from the original elldrazi titans? It feels like a major part of their identity to me, and i was a bit sad to see that none of the titans in MH3 had it.


It doesn’t play well.

Hybrid Mechanic in MH3

New 07 Jul 2024 Asked by mistershinyobject 3 Comments

Why were the two-color MDFC lands in MH3 hybrid? The point of hybrid is "or" not "and," but the backside gives you that other mana anyway. What's the point of a card that says "you don't have to play mana sources of this other color" while also giving you a mana source of that color?


The point is you can play it in a deck of either color without having to support the second color in the deck.

Issues in Play Boosters

New 07 Jul 2024 Asked by guardmanxl 23 Comments

Mark, I play a lot of limited and one thing I've noticed with the new play boosters is that it is no longer guaranteed to have a card of every color in it. This is especially glaring in a set like MKM or MH3 with multicolored commons. In MH3 especially, since there are no colorless commons, I've opened several packs where it is missing a color and the only cards in my other color are multicolored, meaning I basically don't get a 1st pick. Is this a known problem? Is anything being done about it?


The collation only allows us to guarantee four colors and not five.

MH3's Kindred Cards Impact

New 07 Jul 2024 Asked by firefish55 5 Comments

When you learned MH3 would feature new Kindred cards, did you know it would come with such a big influx of people asking about Kindred on Tumblr lol?


I did.

Recurrence of Kindred Mechanic

New 06 Jul 2024 Asked by waywardcomputerthing-blog 20 Comments

Is kindred on the table again? Or that was a "modern horizons can be more complex" thing?


Kindred has a very high bar. That doesn’t mean nothing will reach it again, but it’s not going to be a regular occurence.

Insights on Absorb Mechanic Designs

New 06 Jul 2024 Asked by mytheralmin 28 Comments

Hello, I heard something interesting about MH3 where you retried EVERY mechanic to see what would work with a new context or be interesting. You (WoTC) revisited many of my favorite mechanics like grandeur but didn't for probably my favorite. That mechanic is absorb, and while it has only been keyworded on one card "Lymph Sliver" it did see a continuation on my favorite card of all "Valkmira, Protector's Shield" alongside what would only a few sets later become ward. I wanted to know if you could share any insights on the designs taken with absorb or any other of your favorite mechanics? Thank you very much for your time.


I designed Lymph Sliver and absorb. If I remember correctly, I was riffing off of a shield mechanic from the Star Wars TCG. (It was a trading card game design lead by Richard Garfield that I was on the initial design team for.)


Portions of Marodigest are unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Magic: The Gathering, including card images and mana symbols, is copyright Wizards of the Coast, LLC. Marodigest is not produced by or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. All other content © 2024 Webscape Internet Engineers. All rights reserved.