Simian Spirit Guide

Disparity in Spirit Guide Rarity

New 06 Jul 2024 Asked by zombsidian 27 Comments

Why is Simian Spirit Guide printed at common but Elvish Spirit Guide uncommon?


The Planar Chaos timeshifted sheet did some wonky things to rarities.

Color Pie Mana Acceleration

New 31 Jul 2023 Asked by freezyeazybreezy 43 Comments

will we ever see a simian spirit guide style card in black, blue, or white? if not will ever see a another SSG in R or G?


It’s not an ability that particular fits white orblue’s color pie. Maybe black if it’s accompanied by life loss.

Creature Cost Mechanics

New 10 Jul 2023 Asked by nothingbutland-blog 46 Comments

Would a Black version of Elvish Spirit Guide or Simian Spirit Guide be possible or would it need to create a tapped treaure instead? Or would it require additional payment like lose 1 life?


If we did it, which is a big if, it would probably costs life.

Color Cycle Possibility

New 09 Jul 2023 Asked by throwawayaccountant14 35 Comments

Hi Mark, I'm a big fan of Simian Spirit Guide and Elvish Spirit Guide. Will cards like this be made for the other colors as well, or will this be a Yavimaya/Urborg where only certain colors get it?


It was never intended to be a cycle.

Design Space Limits

New 01 Aug 2022 Asked by natew000 22 Comments

Thinking about cards like Simian Spirit Guide and Faerie Macabre, do you think there is much useful design space in effects where the cost is “Discard this card” or “Exile this card from your hand,” with no additional costs?


They are basically free spells, so there’s a limited amount of design space (that doesn’t have play design issues).

Color Shift Possibility

New 01 Aug 2022 Asked by thatguyovertherewiththething 31 Comments

Could Black get a color shifted Elvish/Simian Spirit Guide if there was some sort of life payment?


It can do it in color pie, but play design might not want to make it.

Black Spirit Guide Inquiry

New 19 Oct 2019 Asked by jax-mtg-blog 39 Comments

Hello. I really really need the black version of Elvish and Simian Spirit Guide, aka Zombie Spirit Guide, for my Oops all Spells deck in Legacy. Any chances to see it printed?


Mana rituals shifted from black to red many, many years ago. Sorry.

Ape Theme Origin

New 09 Dec 2018 Asked by braveswordwielder 54 Comments

With regards to Simian Spirit Guide, the card it’s a riff of, Elvish Spirit Guide, was from Alliances. Alliances had a heavy Ape theme in red, so it’s an Ape because if it had originally been printed in Alliances, that the type it probably would have been.


Good point.

Ape Instead of Goblin

New 08 Dec 2018 Asked by evil-waveform 43 Comments

Why is Simian Spirit Guide an ape instead of a goblin or something else traditionally associated with red?


Planar Chaos’s theme was “alternate present” where Magic evolved differently. We were consciously not doing things as we would normally do them.

Color Alignment

New 25 Nov 2018 Asked by penguinpioneer 24 Comments

Is simian spirit guide more in colour than elvish spirit guide?


The ability is now red. Whether or not it’s something anyone should have play design-wise is up for debate.

Guide Ability Color

New 25 Aug 2015 Asked by damullet 18 Comments

Would you say the Elvish/Simian Spirit Guide ability has definitively moved from Green to Red, or is it still in both colors' toolboxes?


If we do one, it would be more Red than Green.

Spirit Guide Effect

New 05 Jan 2015 Asked by chewypudding 23 Comments

What color would you say currently has the "spirit guide effect?" It seems to work for either red or green, but Simian Spirit Guide has a colorshifted border...


It’s probably Red… If it’s an effect developmentally we want to do.

Color Pie & Rituals

New 06 Nov 2014 Asked by eyeball-frog 26 Comments

Related to the Planar Chaos question, isn't Simian Spirit Guide the correct color for the effect and Elvish Spirit Guide breaking color pie? The effect is essentially a ritual, which is definitely red's thing.


Red is now the color that does temporary mana gain.

Planar Chaos Pie Fidelity

New 06 Nov 2014 Asked by slowishjohnnycube 34 Comments

Thanks to Planar Chaos, there are a number of effects that exist in Modern in the "wrong color," while the right-color version has never been reprinted. Two examples off the top of my head are Simian Spirit Guide/Elvish Spirit Guide (arguably) and Mana Tithe/Force Spike. Do these color pie violations bother you more than others? (They do me.)


Planar Chaos stretched the color pie but not to the point of undercutting the weakness of colors, so those don’t bother me nearly as much as cards that let color’s do things that by color definition they aren’t supposed to be able to do.

Future Spirit Guides?

New 30 May 2012 Asked by chemfy-blog 1 Comments

What is your current opinion on Elvish and Simian Spirit Guide and will we see more Spirit Guides in the future?


They’re playing with fire, so maybe. : )


Portions of Marodigest are unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Magic: The Gathering, including card images and mana symbols, is copyright Wizards of the Coast, LLC. Marodigest is not produced by or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. All other content © 2024 Webscape Internet Engineers. All rights reserved.