Privileged Position

Restrictions Breed Creativity

New 17 Jan 2015 Asked by ayesiwmaeser-blog 69 Comments

I think that restricting addition of hybrid cards in edh games based on colour is really important to the health of the game. You always say restriction breeds creativity. (And the last thing Zur needs is access to is Privileged Position).


By why can’t a monoblack Commander play cards that can be cast in a monoblack deck? That’s my problem. I want cards to have consistency in use across formats.

Hybrid Card Issues

New 17 Jan 2015 Asked by backtrek 94 Comments

Why does Commander forbid playing cards with colors that aren't a subset of your commander's color identity (903.5c), when there's already a rule that any colored mana outside your commander's color identity turns colorless (903.9)? This means that, for example, you can't play Privileged Position in a Zur the Enchanter deck, even though you can cast it with only white mana. Doesn't that defeat the purpose of hybrid cards?


The Commander format currently is not very nice to hybrid cards. It is probably my single greatest issue with the format.

Hexproof Mechanic Query

New 04 Oct 2012 Asked by endertau 9 Comments

Hello, I have a question about the Invisible Stalker creature, which I'm sure you get asked about often. I like hexproof, it is interesting as a mechanic interchangeable between Green and White/Green going back to enchantments like Privileged Position or the creature Silhana Ledgewalker. But why give it to a blue creature? Blue has the shroud mechanic and shroud on an unblockable 1/1 for 1U isn't unreasonable. Hexproof alone was a very undercost mechanic,, but that creature was crazy!


We’ve decided that shroud and hexproof can’t coexist actively in sets because we don’t want two different vocabulary words meaning basically the same thing. Blue originally had shroud and green had hexproof. When we condensed them both blue and green got what we condensed to. At first that meant green got shroud and then blue got hexproof. Blue is the one most in need of creature keywords so I’m not about to start taking ones away from it.


Portions of Marodigest are unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Magic: The Gathering, including card images and mana symbols, is copyright Wizards of the Coast, LLC. Marodigest is not produced by or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. All other content © 2024 Webscape Internet Engineers. All rights reserved.