Arachnus Web

Arachnus Web Question

New 05 Feb 2019 Asked by fatcatlikespudding 24 Comments

Could Arachnus Web be an effect green could have on a creature? Either temporary (like detain) or lasting as long as the creature remains on the battlefield?


Green doesn’t permanently prevent creature activations.

Arachnus Web Comparison

New 05 Feb 2019 Asked by silas-mn 34 Comments

More to play devil’s advocate than anything, but isn’t a card like arachnus web similar to Fog? Where instead of taking all creatures out of combat for a turn, you’re taking one creature out of combat for all turns?


If it just prevented combat damage, maybe, but it does more than that.

Arachnus Web Mechanics

New 05 Feb 2019 Asked by 1pwny 27 Comments

About Arachnus Web requiring a Spider: at least then it’s tied to having creatures, and is therefore closer to being in color pie.


Green can’t do anything if tied to a creature. Only certain effects are tied to creatures.

Arachnus Web Query

New 04 Feb 2019 Asked by forestd3w 23 Comments

Would Arachnus Web be a bend if it required the caster to control a spider?


It being favorable, doesn’t make it any less of a bend. Almost any mechanic can be flavored.

Arachnus Web Evaluation

New 31 Jan 2019 Asked by thewisestmanunderstands 29 Comments

Would Arachnus Web be considered out of color pie today?


It was out of color pie when it was printed. Arrest is a white ability.

Arachnus Web Mechanic

New 05 Mar 2017 Asked by thegreatmill 20 Comments

Would Arachnus Web have been OK if it required a creature as part of the cost? Eg requiring you to tap a Spider you control in order to cast it?


It’s not just an issue of requiring a creature. Green doesn’t take away abilities from other creatures.

Arachnus Web's Color Pie

New 04 Mar 2017 Asked by gustavegraves 12 Comments

Is arachnus web totally out of green's pie or could it work if it were a token or ability made by a creature?


It’s out of Green color pie.

Green's Break Analysis

New 04 Mar 2017 Asked by forestd3w 29 Comments

You said the difference between a bend and a break is a bend doesn't undercut the color's weakness, while a break does. So how is Arachnus Web a break?


One of green’s biggest weakness is being unable to kill creatures without using its own creatures to do so. A creatureless green deck should be unable to answer troublesome creatures. Arachnid Web does exactly that and thus is a pretty major break.

Arachnus Web Analysis

New 04 Mar 2017 Asked by manacharged 28 Comments

How do you feel about Arachnus Web?


It’s a color break. Arrest is White not Green.

Color Pie Boundaries

New 29 Jul 2015 Asked by forgottenghosts 26 Comments

What about Arachnus Web and Beast Within? Are they out of green's colour pie too?


Yep.

Green's Restrictions

New 29 Jul 2015 Asked by theonlymegumegu 23 Comments

Where is arachnus web on color pie validity? Does green get pacifism/arrest effects, or was that a bend/break?


Green is not supposed to get Pacifism. It’s a color pie break.

Krasis Incubation Query

New 22 Apr 2013 Asked by luminumcan-deactivated20170208 6 Comments

I love Krasis Incubation with a fierce passion, but I'm curious if there's any concern on your part about it being a color-pie bleed? Blue and green have had effects like this (Arachnus Web, Ice Cage) but always with a drawback.


It’s completely within green/blue color pie. Note that just because we haven’t done something exactly before doesn’t make it okay within the color pie.


Portions of Marodigest are unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Magic: The Gathering, including card images and mana symbols, is copyright Wizards of the Coast, LLC. Marodigest is not produced by or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast. All other content © 2024 Webscape Internet Engineers. All rights reserved.