Generated on 10 Jul 2024
Based on 424 answers
Trample, one of the earliest mechanics introduced in Magic: The Gathering, has seen many iterations and rule clarifications over the years. Despite its straightforward nature, it remains a mechanic that, surprisingly, many players find confusing. Mark Rosewater, a key figure in Magic's design team, has frequently addressed questions about Trample, illuminating various aspects of its complexity, history, and development. Below is a detailed exploration of his insights on the topic.
Origins and Early Design
Trample, as Rosewater mentions, likely originated from Richard Garfield's top-down design approach. Garfield, the creator of Magic, envisioned creatures that could "trample" over smaller blockers, thus transferring excess combat damage to the defending player. This concept was materialized early in the game's history, and despite the rule adjustments it has undergone, the core idea has remained consistent.
Complexity and Player Confusion
One of the most frequent points Rosewater addresses about Trample is the confusion it causes among players. Despite its clear flavor, the specific interactions— especially when combined with other abilities like Deathtouch— can be quite intricate.
Rosewater acknowledges that a creature with both Deathtouch and Trample can cause excessive confusion. When a creature with both abilities attacks, only one damage is needed to assign lethal damage to each blocker, allowing the rest to trample over. This often leads to scenarios where players misunderstand how much damage gets through to the defending player.
Interestingly, Rosewater remarked, "We’ve made the conscious decision not to put both on the same creature because of the interaction confusion," highlighting this as a deliberate design choice to avoid unnecessary complexity.
Trample's Evergreen Status
Trample is an evergreen mechanic, meaning it is used consistently across many sets. The question of whether it will remain evergreen has been raised, particularly due to its complexity. However, Rosewater has confirmed that Trample is here to stay. "I don’t expect it to get dropped," he said, "Players seem to get the base case use. It’s only when it combines with other effects that it confuses players."
Trample and Combat Dynamics
Understanding how Trample functions within combat has also been a topic of interest. Rosewater frequently gets questions about how Trample interacts with blockers, damage assignment, and effects like Indestructible.
For instance, a common query is, "A 4/4 creature blocks a 4/4 creature with Deathtouch and Trample. How much damage does the player take?" Rosewater explains, "The answer is 3. The first point is considered lethal because of Deathtouch, so the rest can trample over."
Trample in Colors
Trample's distribution among Magic's colors has also been a source of numerous questions. Primarily, Trample is associated with green creatures due to their large size and strength, which fits thematically with the idea of a creature trampling over smaller blockers. Red is secondary in Trample, matching its aggressive and forceful nature.
However, Trample is not exclusive to these colors. Rosewater clarifies that Trample is tertiary in blue, black, and white, though it appears less frequently in these colors. "Trample is tertiary in Blue... because we occasionally make big blue creatures and reserve the right to give them trample if needed," he notes. This explains occasional appearances of blue creatures with Trample, often with some thematic justification such as sea monsters or large animals.
Trample on Non-creature Spells
One of the more interesting discussions about Trample is its potential use on non-creature spells. Despite players' and even Rosewater's interest in the idea, it faces significant rules challenges.
"I’ve tried to make a burn spell with Trample for years. It never works out," Rosewater admits. Cards like Liquid Fire from Odyssey were attempts at creating this effect but ended up being too complex or text-heavy. This limitation has relegated Trample-on-spells to Magic's Un-sets, where the rules can be bent creatively.
Trample in Set Design
The inclusion of Trample in specific sets is often guided by the need to balance limited and constructed play. For instance, in the context of set design, it’s not uncommon to see Trample being used to enable certain play strategies or provide mechanics diversity.
In discussing the heavy hitting common 8/9 trample creature in a set, Rosewater noted, "I think the 8/9 common trampler was a mistake." This highlights both the challenges and learning involved in including such mechanics while maintaining balanced gameplay.
Trivia and Fun Facts
Rosewater's responses are also peppered with trivia and interesting stories. For example, he shared that Rancor— a beloved card— was actually printed incorrectly at a cost of {G} rather than the intended {1}{G}. This unintentional error contributed to its powerful legacy in Magic.
For the flavor purists, Rosewater explains some misconceptions about the flavor fit of Trample across creatures. "Trample represents the inertia of a giant creature. Its size and/or momentum allows it to trample over the smaller creature blocking it," he explains, which can include flying creatures.
Evolution in Rules and Design Philosophy
Over time, how Trample fits within the overall game design has evolved. One area is its intersection with other mechanics. For instance, bringing back the mechanic for a green-focused Limited environment may lead to its intentional omission to preserve interaction with smaller creatures and maintain game balance.
Another evolution is how Trample is presented on cards. While early iterations were more straightforward, modern design often considers interaction complexities more meticulously.
In summary, Trample remains a fundamental yet nuanced mechanic within Magic: The Gathering. Rosewater's responses highlight the careful balance between complexity and flavor, continual efforts to teach and streamline gameplay, and the fun stories and thoughtful decisions shaping this enduring ability.
As Rosewater succinctly put it, "I’ve been trying to get a direct damage with trample in the game for twenty years," underscoring the passion and persistence behind evolving Magic's mechanics, even the ones as familiar as Trample.
Trample, one of the earliest mechanics introduced in Magic: The Gathering, has seen many iterations and rule clarifications over the years. Despite its straightforward nature, it remains a mechanic that, surprisingly, many players find confusing. Mark Rosewater, a key figure in Magic's design team, has frequently addressed questions about Trample, illuminating various aspects of its complexity, history, and development. Below is a detailed exploration of his insights on the topic.
Origins and Early Design
Trample, as Rosewater mentions, likely originated from Richard Garfield's top-down design approach. Garfield, the creator of Magic, envisioned creatures that could "trample" over smaller blockers, thus transferring excess combat damage to the defending player. This concept was materialized early in the game's history, and despite the rule adjustments it has undergone, the core idea has remained consistent.
Complexity and Player Confusion
One of the most frequent points Rosewater addresses about Trample is the confusion it causes among players. Despite its clear flavor, the specific interactions— especially when combined with other abilities like Deathtouch— can be quite intricate.
Rosewater acknowledges that a creature with both Deathtouch and Trample can cause excessive confusion. When a creature with both abilities attacks, only one damage is needed to assign lethal damage to each blocker, allowing the rest to trample over. This often leads to scenarios where players misunderstand how much damage gets through to the defending player.
Interestingly, Rosewater remarked, "We’ve made the conscious decision not to put both on the same creature because of the interaction confusion," highlighting this as a deliberate design choice to avoid unnecessary complexity.
Trample's Evergreen Status
Trample is an evergreen mechanic, meaning it is used consistently across many sets. The question of whether it will remain evergreen has been raised, particularly due to its complexity. However, Rosewater has confirmed that Trample is here to stay. "I don’t expect it to get dropped," he said, "Players seem to get the base case use. It’s only when it combines with other effects that it confuses players."
Trample and Combat Dynamics
Understanding how Trample functions within combat has also been a topic of interest. Rosewater frequently gets questions about how Trample interacts with blockers, damage assignment, and effects like Indestructible.
For instance, a common query is, "A 4/4 creature blocks a 4/4 creature with Deathtouch and Trample. How much damage does the player take?" Rosewater explains, "The answer is 3. The first point is considered lethal because of Deathtouch, so the rest can trample over."
Trample in Colors
Trample's distribution among Magic's colors has also been a source of numerous questions. Primarily, Trample is associated with green creatures due to their large size and strength, which fits thematically with the idea of a creature trampling over smaller blockers. Red is secondary in Trample, matching its aggressive and forceful nature.
However, Trample is not exclusive to these colors. Rosewater clarifies that Trample is tertiary in blue, black, and white, though it appears less frequently in these colors. "Trample is tertiary in Blue... because we occasionally make big blue creatures and reserve the right to give them trample if needed," he notes. This explains occasional appearances of blue creatures with Trample, often with some thematic justification such as sea monsters or large animals.
Trample on Non-creature Spells
One of the more interesting discussions about Trample is its potential use on non-creature spells. Despite players' and even Rosewater's interest in the idea, it faces significant rules challenges.
"I’ve tried to make a burn spell with Trample for years. It never works out," Rosewater admits. Cards like Liquid Fire from Odyssey were attempts at creating this effect but ended up being too complex or text-heavy. This limitation has relegated Trample-on-spells to Magic's Un-sets, where the rules can be bent creatively.
Trample in Set Design
The inclusion of Trample in specific sets is often guided by the need to balance limited and constructed play. For instance, in the context of set design, it’s not uncommon to see Trample being used to enable certain play strategies or provide mechanics diversity.
In discussing the heavy hitting common 8/9 trample creature in a set, Rosewater noted, "I think the 8/9 common trampler was a mistake." This highlights both the challenges and learning involved in including such mechanics while maintaining balanced gameplay.
Trivia and Fun Facts
Rosewater's responses are also peppered with trivia and interesting stories. For example, he shared that Rancor— a beloved card— was actually printed incorrectly at a cost of {G} rather than the intended {1}{G}. This unintentional error contributed to its powerful legacy in Magic.
For the flavor purists, Rosewater explains some misconceptions about the flavor fit of Trample across creatures. "Trample represents the inertia of a giant creature. Its size and/or momentum allows it to trample over the smaller creature blocking it," he explains, which can include flying creatures.
Evolution in Rules and Design Philosophy
Over time, how Trample fits within the overall game design has evolved. One area is its intersection with other mechanics. For instance, bringing back the mechanic for a green-focused Limited environment may lead to its intentional omission to preserve interaction with smaller creatures and maintain game balance.
Another evolution is how Trample is presented on cards. While early iterations were more straightforward, modern design often considers interaction complexities more meticulously.
In summary, Trample remains a fundamental yet nuanced mechanic within Magic: The Gathering. Rosewater's responses highlight the careful balance between complexity and flavor, continual efforts to teach and streamline gameplay, and the fun stories and thoughtful decisions shaping this enduring ability.
As Rosewater succinctly put it, "I’ve been trying to get a direct damage with trample in the game for twenty years," underscoring the passion and persistence behind evolving Magic's mechanics, even the ones as familiar as Trample.